Blue slips are back in the news after the Biden administration thought it had a consensus candidate for a judgeship in Mississippi, only for it to be blocked at the last minute by a Republican senator. Let's listen in:
Republicans abandoned the blue-slip process for appeals court judges after gaining control of the Senate in 2015, allowing them to rapidly confirm scores of Donald J. Trump’s judicial nominees over Democratic objections. But the practice was retained for district court judges, and Mr. Durbin has been reluctant to jettison it, fearing Republicans would retaliate by bringing the confirmation process to a standstill.
“You always have to ask, ‘What would they do in response?’” Mr. Durbin said in an interview. “There are an infinite array of possibilities to slow down the United States Senate. Anyone can stop the train for any reason.”
Let me get this straight. Republicans abandoned blue slips completely for appellate judges when Trump was president and then proceeded to fill the circuit courts with right-wing picks. Nothing happened.
Today, Dick Durbin is reluctant to abandon blue slips for one district court judgeship because Republicans might retaliate: "There are an infinite array of possibilities to slow down the United States Senate," he explains.
Out of that infinite array, did Democrats use any of them to slow down the tsunami of Trump judges? Why not? Does this array even exist? And why do Democrats even care about slowing down the Senate since Republicans control the House and no business is going to be transacted anyway?
Republicans have been playing games with blue slips for decades and Democrats have never retaliated, apparently in hopes that Republicans will someday come to their senses and start behaving decently. What will it take to finally disabuse them of that notion?