I've seen a lot of commentary about the Trump trial vaguely suggesting that it popped up out of nowhere from a partisan DA with an axe to grind and a dubious legal theory he invented just for the occasion. This is not true.
It is true that the legal theory behind Trump's prosecution was novel, but that's because no one had ever before done what Trump did. Nor was it invented especially by Alvin Bragg. The prospect of prosecuting Trump for falsifying business records to conceal criminal conduct has been repeatedly discussed since shortly after the day federal prosecutors first revealed that Trump's hush money payments were fraudulently booked as legal expenses. That was nearly five years ago.
Since then, the hush money case has been under continual investigation by US Attorneys, the Federal Election Commission, the New York State attorney general, and the Manhattan district attorney. It was slowed down by federal prosecutors, Trump appeals, and a changing of the guard in the Manhattan DA's office. But it never went away.
To refresh your memory about how long and continuously this case has been in the news, here's a brief timeline.
November 2016: The Wall Street Journal reports that the National Enquirer paid Karen McDougal, a Playboy model, $150,000 to buy her silence about an affair with Donald Trump.
January 2018: The Journal reports that Trump fixer Michael Cohen paid hush money directly to porn star Stormy Daniels for the same reason. Trump denies everything.
July 2018: CNN releases audiotape of Trump discussing hush money payments with Cohen.
August 2018: Federal prosecutors reveal that Cohen's reimbursements were booked as legal expenses by The Trump Organization.
August 2018: The Manhattan DA, Cyrus Vance, considers opening an investigation into the hush money case. Federal prosecutors will later ask him to pause his investigation until theirs is finished.
November 2018: The Journal confirms that Trump was personally involved with both hush money payments.
December 2018: Federal prosecutors make public a non-prosecution agreement signed with AMI, the parent company of the National Enquirer. It states that the hush money payments were intended to prevent damage to Trump's 2016 campaign.
July 2019: Federal prosecutors conclude their hush money investigation without charges. Federal rules prevent prosecution of a sitting president.
August 2019: With the federal investigation over, Manhattan DA Cyrus Vance re-opens his investigation and subpoenas Trump for hush money documents.
May 2021: After an investigation, the Federal Election Commission concludes that AMI violated campaign finance laws by secretly paying McDougal.
November 2021: Vance convenes grand jury to hear evidence against Trump.
January 2022: Alvin Bragg takes office as new Manhattan DA.
February 2022: Two prosecutors leave DA's office over disappointment that Bragg didn't immediately bring charges against Trump.
December 2022: Bragg hires a former DOJ attorney who worked the federal investigation of Trump.
April 2023: Bragg indicts Trump for falsifying business records in order to conceal damaging information during the 2016 election.
May 2024: Trump is convicted on all counts.