It's not over yet, but things are looking grim for Kamala Harris. Was it all down to inflation?
Every incumbent party around the world when the post-pandemic inflation began has lost, regardless of ideology and regardless of where inflation was at the moment of the election.
— David Dayen (@ddayen) November 6, 2024
Here's what the exit polls say about inflation over the past year:
Needless to say, this is crazy. It's perfectly sensible to see big partisan disagreements about abortion or guns or taxes. But a huge partisan split on how much inflation has hurt you?
I think we can say that, obviously, inflation affected everyone roughly the same. It didn't affect Republicans any more harshly than Democrats—not by more than a handful of percentage points anyway. And yet a huge number say it was a severe hardship over the past year. The past year! There's hardly been any inflation over the past year.¹ Maybe Annie Lowrey has it right:
Since I've been a reporter, so since the GWB administration, it's been clear that headline economy statistics have become less and less of a clear guide in terms of telling you what average families are feeling.
— Annie Lowrey (@AnnieLowrey) November 6, 2024
Perhaps. But even assuming that people interpret "the past year" as "ever since Biden took over," it still doesn't make sense that the partisan divide would be so big. This isn't the kind of question that automatically triggers tribal identification, the way some questions do.
In the end, it might be the simplest of things: inflation made people mad. And when they're mad they vote for the out party. They don't care whose fault it was or anything like that. They're just mad, so they vote for a change.
Or maybe it was Fox News banging away about inflation 24/7.
Or maybe there are still just too many men who simply can't bring themselves to vote for a woman. Especially among Latinos.
Maybe, maybe, maybe.
¹2.4% to be exact, almost exactly the average from 2000-2019.