In the New York Times today, Jamelle Bouie fires away at moderate Democrats who, he says, derailed President Biden's agenda and are now trying to blame progressives for their own failure.
I don't understand this. It's true, as Bouie says, that over the summer there was disagreement about whether to link the infrastructure bill and the social spending bill. Progressives wanted to pass them together while moderates wanted to vote on them separately. "That brought the Democratic Party’s momentum to a sudden halt."
Sure, I guess, but only because both sides stuck to their guns. I don't see how you can exclusively blame either moderates or progressives for this. Then this:
Nor have moderate and conservative Democrats tried to devise an agenda of their own. Instead, they’ve used their remaining political capital to kill the most popular items on the Democratic Party wish list, from tax hikes on the richest Americans and an increase in the minimum wage to a plan for price controls on prescription drugs. They couldn’t even be bothered to save the revamped child tax credit, one of the most effective antipoverty measures since at least the Great Society. Its expiration in December pushed millions of children back under the poverty line.
This doesn't make any sense. Practically every Democratic senator, moderate and progressive alike, supported all this stuff. It failed specifically because of two prickly senators, Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema. This says nothing at all about either moderates or progressives.
In any case, the real gripe among moderates has nothing to do with the social spending bill—which, again, they supported. Passing it would have been good for the country, but no one thinks either its success or failure will have the slightest impact on the political fortunes of Democrats this November. Rather, the moderate complaints are all about cultural stuff: defunding the police, CRT, immigration, and so forth.
That's the battleground, not the spending bill. And I'll say this: I'm generally sympathetic to the moderates on cultural issues. At the same time, if they think progressive cultural views are damaging the party, they need to fight back. If they instead stay silent because they're afraid of criticism, then they have no one but their own cowardly selves to blame if the rest of the world thinks that progressive views define the entire Democratic Party. Either speak up or accept responsibility for your silence. That's how politics works.