The Washington Post has a story about yet another school that uses Yondr pouches to prevent cell phone use during the day:
Administrators said some of the changes among students have surprised them. Group vaping sessions where students would coordinate to meet in restrooms to smoke prohibited electronic cigarettes? Finished. Using AirDrop to share inappropriate photos during class? No more. Social-media-fueled arguments during school? Over.
Interesting! But what was more interesting was the anecdotal evidence that after a little while even the students themselves liked it:
Multiple students have told him they feel like they are making more friends. His gut also tells him that “the angsty intensity kids are living under” — he mimicked a person with head down, lost in a screen — has diminished.
Students confirmed that the disappearance of cellphones has, in turn, stimulated something old-fashioned.... When the pouches first arrived, “everyone was miserable and no one was talking to each other,” he said. Now he can hear the difference at lunch and in the hallways. It’s louder. Students are chatting more “face to face, in person,” Gabe said. “And that’s a crucial part of growing up.”
Some students hadn’t realized how much their phones diverted their focus....It turns out that being separated from your phone for the day isn’t as big a deal as some students feared. “People thought, ‘Oh my God, I’m going to miss so much,’” Nicole said. “You don’t miss anything. Nothing important is happening outside school.”
I have consistently argued that the evidence of cell phones causing serious problems among teens is pretty thin. That's what the evidence says. But I believe this even though my gut feeling agrees entirely with the anti-phone crowd.¹ This article confirms my gut feeling, but of course "we talk more" is hardly evidence that cell phones are genuinely causing depression or suicide or brain rewiring among teens.
In any case, the entire piece is worth reading. Aside from anything else, I continue to believe that the argument for banning cell phones during the school day is very convincing. Whatever else they may or may not do, they're certainly a distraction for kids who are supposed to be paying attention in class. And there's certainly no harm in teens having an oasis away from social media for a few hours every day.
¹I mostly attribute my gut feeling to the fact that I'm 65 and didn't grow up with cell phones. I suspect that this is responsible for a lot of anti-phone sentiment.