Are Black drivers ticketed by police more than white drivers? A new study suggests they are. It compares tickets given via police vs. tickets given by speed cameras and finds that cameras treat everyone about the same while police decidedly don't. Here's the key chart:
The red and blue lines are for camera tickets. They're very close, suggesting that, objectively, Black and white drivers are driving about the same.
The green and magenta lines are for police tickets. Black drivers are ticketed at rates above speed cameras, but more notably, white drivers are ticketed at rates way under speed cameras. This gap is more noticeable the whiter an area is.
The study estimates the race of drivers based on where they live, which is obviously not 100% accurate. However, over the course of thousands of observations it probably averages out about right.
The best conclusion from this study is not that Black drivers are ticketed way more than they should be. It's that white drivers are routinely treated leniently in ways Black drivers aren't. You may be tired of the phrase "white privilege," but this is what it is.