To refresh your memory, here is the list of major items in the $3.5 trillion reconciliation bill:
- Makes the increased Obamacare subsidies from January's coronavirus bill permanent.
- Provides universal pre-K for 3- and 4-year-olds.
- Provides funding for long-term care done at home.
- Provides two years of free community college.
- Makes the increased child tax credit permanent.
- Adds dental, hearing, and vision benefits to Medicare.
- Funds various climate initiatives.
Since Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema are demanding that the cost of the bill be reduced, much of the conversation has been around which items to keep and which to abandon. To my dismay, but not to my surprise, my #1 item appears to be on no one's keeper list.
The reason for this is obvious but rarely discussed: Democrats are so committed to helping the poor that they ignore practically everyone else. The increased Obamacare subsidies would primarily help the middle class, which means they have very little support compared to other items on the list.
This is admirable, but it can also become self-defeating. Over the past few decades, the only help the middle class has gotten from anyone has been in the form of tax cuts from Republicans. That hasn't benefited the middle class a lot, but it's better than nothing—which is roughly what they've gotten from Democrats.

Democrats desperately need to address this. They spend a lot of time scratching their chins and wondering why the white working/middle class doesn't vote for them, and inevitably they decide that it's all about racism or religion. And some of it is. Somehow, though, Democrats never manage to acknowledge that they do virtually nothing to help middle-class voters. They're keen on helping the poor; and the disabled; and the elderly; and the marginalized—but not the broad middle class. After all, "they should quit griping, they're still better off than the poor."
This is a recipe for electoral disaster, which is pretty much what's happened. Democrats have abandoned the middle class and then seem perplexed when the middle class abandons them. The middle class deserves better, something that Democrats used to know. They need to relearn it.