In the Wall Street Journal today, Greg Ip cites a poll suggesting that President Biden has a bigger problem than inflation:
Twice as many respondents named immigration as the biggest issue in next year’s election as inflation. His disapproval on the border exceeded approval by 37 percentage points, compared with 36 points for inflation.
Not that it is much comfort, but Biden has company: Surging immigration is a global phenomenon, as tight labor markets attract migrants, often helped by sophisticated smugglers. It is also a political albatross for incumbents in countries that, like the U.S., have long been major recipients of immigrants.
Regular readers know that I agree about this on both pragmatic grounds and ethical ones. Pragmatically, it's just a fact that high levels of immigration provoke opposition that leads to right-wing backlash. Ethically, it's perfectly natural for modern nation states to control their borders and limit illegal immigration.
That said, Ip includes a chart that largely throws cold water on this whole conversation:
This shows two things. First, immigration in the US has long been considerably smaller than in other countries. Second, the absolute level of immigration is not a lot higher now than it has been for the past decade, a period of little net growth in the total immigrant population.
Now, it's worth saying immediately that I have my doubts about this chart. I'm not sure where the information for the US comes from, and it's not clear if it really accounts for all illegal immigration. That said, if it was honestly done it does suggest that net immigration has not been nearly as bad as our border hysteria suggests.
But that probably doesn't matter. In 2016 the population of illegal immigrants in the US was on a long downward trend, but Donald Trump nonetheless used it as a powerful weapon in his campaign. In the face of that, as well as obviously high numbers of asylum seekers crowding the southern border, it's not likely that dry facts will have much effect. If Biden is smart, he'll accept Republican restrictions on illegal immigration in the Ukraine aid bill and then pray that they have a noticeable effect before next year's election.